Review Guidelines
DRAFT – needs counsel review. Placeholder product name "the directory" (PRD Q1 open). Two points need counsel: the FTC fake-review rule and the Consumer Review Fairness Act (see section 7). ABUSE-5 asks for counsel and writer review of this document.
1. What this page covers
Reviews are written by people who used a groomer. This page says what we accept, what we reject, and how we decide. The same rules apply to every listing, whether the business is large or small, paying or not.
2. What we accept
A review should be:
- About a real visit or a real experience with the groomer.
- Your own honest opinion, positive or negative.
- Between 50 and 2,000 characters. Stars from 1 to 5. A visit month is optional.
- Free of personal information about you or anyone else.
Negative reviews are welcome. A review does not need to be balanced, fair or polite to be accepted, as long as it meets the rules below.
3. What we reject
We reject a review if it is:
| Reason code | What it means |
|---|---|
| spam | Advertising, links to other businesses, repeated text, or a review posted for payment |
| conflict_of_interest | The reviewer owns, works for, or is paid by the business, or competes with it (see section 4) |
| off_topic | Not about the groomer's service (for example, a review about a different business or a political rant) |
| abusive | Threats, harassment, slurs, or hateful content aimed at a person |
| personal_info | Names, phone numbers, home addresses, pictures of people, or the personal details of a staff member or another customer |
We do not reject a review because it is negative, because the reviewer is angry, or because we disagree with the reviewer.
4. Conflict of interest
These rules are applied before a review goes live.
- Owners and staff cannot review their own business. This includes anyone with an approved claim, anyone with a pending claim, and anyone who works at the business.
- Owners and staff cannot review a competitor where they could benefit from the review. Examples are a groomer reviewing a nearby groomer in the same service, or the same owner posting reviews for two of their own listings. This is decided by staff on the facts, not by the reviewer's word.
- A reviewer must disclose any payment or incentive for the review. We reject a review that was paid for or given in exchange for a benefit.
- A reviewer who later becomes an owner of a listing loses the right to keep their review of that listing. Their earlier review is hidden on approval of their claim (ABUSE-5).
When a conflict is found, the review is rejected with the conflict_of_interest code. We tell the reviewer the reason.
A report from the business that is the subject of a review is not treated as evidence. Staff judge it like any other report.
5. How reviews are moderated
- All reviews are pre-moderated: they are held until staff approve them.
- Staff use the same checklist every time (section 3 and 4).
- A review that is reported 3 or more times from different people is hidden until staff decide. Reports from the listing's owner or staff do not count towards auto-hiding; they still go to the queue.
- An edited review goes back into moderation.
- Staff who approve or reject a review record the reason in the audit log.
We do not hide reviews on request from a business. A business can reply publicly to a review (one reply per review, moderated), and it can report a review through the same process as anyone else.
6. Suspicious activity we flag for staff
These do not cause automatic rejection. They put the review at the top of the queue:
- A new account (less than 7 days old) posting a review.
- Many reviews of one listing in a short time (5 or more in 24 hours).
- Several reviews from the same IP address or device.
- A review that repeats text found in another review.
- A sign-up with a disposable email address.
Staff check the signals and decide. Signals are never shown to the public.
7. Points for counsel
- FTC rule on consumer reviews (16 CFR Part 465, effective October 2024). The rule bans fake or paid reviews, buying reviews, and review suppression by intimidation or threats. Confirm that the conflict-of-interest rule, the "disclose any payment" rule and the staff-judgement process meet the rule, and that we are not "suppressing" reviews by rejecting critical ones. [counsel]
- Consumer Review Fairness Act (15 U.S.C. § 45b). Form contracts may not restrict a person's ability to post reviews. Confirm that the Terms of Service (section 5) and the business owner terms do not restrict reviews, and that owners cannot make a review removal a condition of a service. [counsel]
- Whether the moderation process could be called "pre-moderation of negative reviews" if the rejection rate for negative reviews is higher. We propose to publish a monthly count of rejections by reason. [counsel]
- Retention of rejected reviews and the reviewer's data. [counsel]
8. Changes
We update this page when the rules change. The date at the top shows the version.
Related: Terms of Service · Privacy Policy · DMCA and Takedowns